10 Bold Predictions for 2012: Justin Upton & the Arizona Diamondbacks Regress

As part of our preview for the upcoming 2012 season, we’ll be doing a 10 Bold Predictions for 2012 series that will be featured between now and Opening Day. Our sixth prediction is that Justin Upton and the Arizona Diamondbacks are in for a long 2012 campaign.

Justin Upton was unbelievable last season. If it weren’t for J-Up and his motley crew that made up the rest of the band, what would we have possibly done with ourselves down the stretch run? As unheralded and unlikely as the Diamondbacks were, they came so very close to reaching the NLCS last fall.

Upton had a season that will always stand out on the back of his baseball card as his breakout performance. He finished 4th in MVP balloting with a .289 average, 31 home runs, 105 runs, 88 RBI, and 21 stolen bases. His slash line was a pretty .369/.529/.898, falling just short of that rare .900 OPS air. He was a 6.4 fWAR player at age 23, entering even more rare company.

And now it all comes crashing down for Upton, at least somewhat. A large part of his success last season was because he appeared in 159 names, such is always half the battle in putting together a big time season. We’re going to predict a season in which he has a production similar to 2010 (.273, 17 HR, 69 RBI, .356/.442/.799). And it’s going to be due to a catastrophic injury of some type that limits his playing time to less than 120 games rather than regression of ability. That’s the only thing that bring a talent like Upton’s to a screeching halt at this point.

It’s not due to any data or evidence either. Like with all of our predictions, this one deals with gut feeling. We don’t think it’s likely that Upton strings together another season in which he playas in over 150 games. Maybe it’s because we took him with our first pick in fantasy baseball in one of our most important leagues–and things like that just usually don’t work out for us. But we feel that something out there will keep Upton from staying on the path of becoming the next Junior Griffey type talent of baseball.

And such leads to the snowball of the Diamondbacks who will go as Upton goes in 2012, and they know it.

Kirk Gibson willed this team to 94 regular season wins in 2011, no small feat when your regulars were guys like Gerardo Parra, Ryan Roberts and Willie Bloomquist among others. A summer to remember it will be, especially when the Diamondbacks struggle to get to 75 wins in 2012.

Another guy we see the regression grim reaper coming for in a large way is closer J.J. Putz. He was a strength last year with 45 saves and a 2.12 ERA, but he’ll be 35 this season and last season’s remarkable performance came on the heels of three straight up and down campaigns for Putz. Expect David Hernandez to emerge as the closer by mid-season for one reason or another.

We think that Daniel Hudson will actually be a lot better in 2012, but there’s no way Ian Kennedy goes 21-4 with a 2.88 ERA again. Trevor Cahill, Joe Saunders, and Josh Collmenter won’t combine to do much for you after those two, either.

Everyone is predicting a breakout year for Paul Goldschmidt whom we love, but 30 homer projections are probably a year early at this point. Stephen Drew is banged up and the scab under the band-aid peels completely off this season, while guys like Roberts and Chris Young settle in to who they really are as players rather than having career years again.

This team will finish no greater than third in the NL West to pitching rich San Francisco and the underrated Rockies.

  • Seems like that gut feeling is because you have eaten something that doesn’t agree with you, so you take it out on the DBacks and J-Up..Maybe it’s just wishful thinking. The DBacks are so loaded with talent that they have a Gold glover who posted a .292 Ba that might not be in the starting line up. Back to J-Up, this team is so deep that “if” some kind of bad luck comes to J-Up theres is a rookie at first base that is very capable of filling in the numbers. No team in the West is going to take anything away from the DBacks , Nuff said !

  • I hope you’re right.

  • Yeah i agree too even though with that trials he can still stand up to fight of what they had started right?

  • Patrik

    I thought i was on a D-Backs page, but all the negativity and disrespecting of the current players made me scroll back to the top to make sure…. What kind of fan are you? The way you talk about the players on this team you would think they don’t even belong in the big leagues. J-Up is a Elite talent and to pretty much say what he did last year was a fluke is ignorant. As for Ian Kennedy winning 20 games again this season is not likely but that don’t mean that his season will be a failure, in the past 20 years only 11 pitchers have multiple 20 win seasons. You also say J.J. Putz wont be successful this year because he is 35?… really? Maybe you should make your way to the Rockies camp and tell Jamie Moyer that, he is 49 and just landed a spot in there rotation. Maybe you should give more credit to the manager, baseball is a team sport it takes everyone believing in each other and believing in what the manager is trying to accomplish. Whens the last time a franchise who bought there lineup won a World Series? And one last thing before i go, most of the players who become stars in this league are not first round picks or even second round. So give these guys a chance and have some pride for your team instead of calling what they did last year a “fluke” and putting them in the cellar of the division before the season even starts.

  • Ok guys. Lets take a deep breath. Lets get a few things straight
    – J Up is an absolute stud who will only get slowed down by injuries (as was written in the article).
    – Gibson is a great manager and the D’Backs feed off of his energy and focus he brings to the ballpark everyday.

    And my final point and reason why all of this doesn’t matter at all:
    -The Dodgers are going to RUN OVER the NL West this year and straight dominate. D’Backs and everyone else are playing for 2nd.

    (drop the microphone, and walk away with my hands in the air dramatically)